Phase 1 · Current State
A snapshot of where the brand stands, and where it can go next.
Customer trust
A perfect 5.0 on Trustpilot across 3,600 verified reviews. Two years running as the top-rated jewelry brand on the platform.
"Customers name specific staff by first name in reviews. Matthew, Cait, and CEO Ajay Anand appear repeatedly. That is not a support score. That is a relationship score."
Hover for research →Tap for research →
Price transparency
The Rare Carat Report checks every diamond against the full market before you buy. Over a million diamonds analyzed.
"Most jewelry sites have an incentive to obscure pricing. Rare Carat built its reputation on exposing it. The Report uses 50 data points per stone to flag quality and pricing issues before purchase."
Hover for research →Tap for research →
Human expertise
Over 100 GIA-certified gemologists on chat 24/7. No sales pressure. No upsell. Just expert guidance.
"Every other major online diamond retailer either charges for expert access or does not offer it at all. Rare Carat makes it the default experience for every customer."
Hover for research →Tap for research →
Pricing advantage
No showrooms, no middlemen. Rare Carat routes orders through vetted wholesalers so savings go to the buyer, not the storefront.
"Comparable diamonds typically run 20 to 40% cheaper on Rare Carat than at traditional jewelry stores on equivalent specs. The model removes the retail markup without removing the service layer."
Hover for research →Tap for research →
Editorial credibility
The New York Times, Forbes, CNBC, NPR, and Harvard Business School have all written about Rare Carat without being paid to do so.
"The New York Times called it the secret to buying the perfect diamond. CEO Ajay Anand sits on Forbes 30 Under 30 judging panels. Harvard Business School published a case study on the company. That kind of coverage cannot be bought."
Hover for research →Tap for research →
Trust gap
Shopping for a $5,000 stone from a photo alone creates real doubt. Video quality across the site varies by supplier.
"Rare Carat's video quality varies by supplier, a direct observation from professional diamond buyers. When a customer is spending $5,000 on something they can't touch, inconsistent visuals create doubt at the worst possible moment."
Hover for research →Tap for research →
Pre-purchase anxiety
Customers wait 2-3 weeks for delivery with no way to try the ring before it arrives. That's a long time to second-guess a $5,000 decision.
"68% of luxury shoppers abandon purchases because they can't see product details adequately. A 2-3 week build time with no preview creates real anxiety. With Clarity solved this with free home replicas. Rare Carat has no equivalent."
Hover for research →Tap for research →
Shopping behavior
Nearly half of couples now shop for rings together. The site has no way to accommodate two people making one decision.
"46% of couples now jointly shop for engagement rings. The site has no shared wishlist, no couples mode, no his-and-hers experience. That's nearly half the market shopping in a system designed for someone else."
Hover for research →Tap for research →
Post-purchase relationship
After purchase, there's no milestone engine, no anniversary triggers, no reason for a happy customer to come back. The relationship stops at checkout.
"The average couple buys an engagement ring, then a wedding band, then anniversary pieces over decades. Research shows post-purchase follow-up and relationship continuity are key loyalty drivers in jewelry. Rare Carat has no milestone engine, no anniversary triggers, no structured reason for a happy customer to return."
Hover for research →Tap for research →
Personalization
There's no persistent profile. Return visitors see the same generic experience as first-timers, even after expressing clear preferences in a previous chat.
"84% of shoppers say personalization matters when deciding where to buy. Return visitors to Rare Carat see the same generic experience as first-timers, with no memory of previous chats, preferences, or searches. Every restart is a conversion risk."
Hover for research →Tap for research →